t
would have been comical had it not been so tragic. There was Yasir
Arafat in Ramallah on Wednesday lecturing the Palestinian legislature
on the need to make the Palestinian Authority more democratic, accountable
and transparent. Here was the man who had spent six years marginalizing
the very group he was addressing — who had never signed the Basic
Law passed by the legislature that established a separation of powers
— demanding "firmer bases of democracy, rule of law, independent
judiciary."
Mr. Arafat
made no promises and offered no specifics in his speech. But yesterday,
after a group of Palestinian legislators presented him with a list
of reforms, a spokesman for the Palestinian leader announced that
Mr. Arafat was willing to hold elections within six months. While
that alone is hardly the most urgent step, his announcement suggested
that the smoldering five-year-old effort to radically reform his
corrupt and dictatorial government may have started to catch fire.
Washington needs to do everything it can to encourage this development.
If Palestine can become more democratic, the chances of peace with
Israel will be greatly enhanced. It could also serve as a model
for the entire Arab world.
There are plenty
of reasons to be skeptical of Mr. Arafat's intentions and of the
possibility of reform. He has concentrated power so completely in
his own hands that he approves all senior officials' vacations and
their per diem expenses. His justice minister got so tired of the
fact that there was no judicial system that he quit. The public-sector
bureaucracy is so bloated with patronage jobs that it is two to
three times the size it needs to be. Five years ago a Palestinian
parliamentary committee found that Mr. Arafat's bureaucracy was
so riddled with corruption that it recommended it be dissolved and
some of its members put on trial.
The road to
Palestinian reform is clear. Mr. Arafat signs the Basic Law — passed
five years ago — that establishes three separate branches of government.
He reduces his cabinet size to 18 or 19. An independent judiciary
is set up. The dozen security services are consolidated into one
under the authority of a civilian. The ministry of finance is strengthened
so that it can become accountable to the legislature and have the
capacity to establish a budget and supervise expenditures. A civil
service is set up in which merit outweighs loyalty. A constitution
is adopted. New elections are set.
Ideally, a
new parliamentary system will emerge and Mr. Arafat will end up
as a figurehead president with power invested in a prime minister.
The Bush administration
is sending George Tenet, the director of central intelligence, to
help the Palestinians streamline their security services. That is
a good step. But it must persuade Israel that, as vital as these
changes are, internal Palestinian reforms have to be accompanied
by negotiations over Israeli withdrawal and the establishment of
a Palestinian state. Without the promise of a breakthrough on that
front, the issue of occupation will again overwhelm the Palestinian
agenda.